Skip to main content
  • dva.gov.au
  • anzaccentenary.gov.au

The Anzac Portal

Home
Home
  • Home
  • History
    • Conflicts
      • Gallipoli and the Anzacs
      • Australians on the Western Front
      • Australia and the Second World War
      • The Burma-Thailand Railway and Hellfire Pass
      • The Kokoda Track
      • Australian involvement in South-East Asian conflicts
      • The Korean War
      • Australia and the Vietnam War
    • Special features
      • Veterans' stories
      • Great War memories
      • Victoria Cross recipients
  • Education
    • Education
      • Year 9 History resources
      • Year 10 History resources
      • Anzac Day resources for primary schools
      • All education resources
    • Competitions
      • Anzac Day Schools' Awards
    • Curriculum units
    • Online activities
      • Coming Home: An investigation of the Armistice and Repatriation
      • Keeping the Peace: Investigating Australia's contribution to peacekeeping
  • Multimedia
    • Audio
    • Documents
    • Images
    • Publications
      • 1916—Fromelles and the Somme
      • 1917—Bapaume and Bullecourt
      • 1917—Ypres
      • 1918—Amiens to Hindenburg Line
      • 1918—Villers-Bretonneux to Le Hamel
      • A Bitter Fate—Australians In Malaya & Singapore
      • Ancestry—Stories of multicultural Anzacs
      • Audacity—Stories of heroic Australians in wartime
      • Australian Flying Corps
      • Australian Light Horse—Palestine 1916–1918
      • Bomber Command
      • Candour: Stories in the words of those who served 1914—18
      • Chinese Anzacs
      • Comradeship—Stories of friendship and recreation in wartime
      • Curiosity—Stories of those who report during wartime
      • Decision—Stories of Leadership in the Services
      • Devotion—Stories of Australia's Wartime Nurses
      • Forever Yours
      • Gallipoli
      • Greece and Crete
      • Home Front
      • Laden, Fevered, Starved—the POWs of Sandakan
      • Memories and Memorabilia
      • North Africa and Syria
      • North Beach Gallipoli 1915
      • Operation Jaywick
      • Resource—Stories of innovation in wartime
      • Royal Australian Navy
      • Royal Australian Navy in the Atlantic and Mediterranean
      • The sinking of the Centaur
      • United Kingdom
      • Valuing our veterans
      • World Wide Effort: Australia's Peacekeepers
    • Videos
  • Anzac Day Schools’ Awards Winners
  • Conduct an event
    • Multimedia
    • Resources
    • Sample Speeches
  • Resources
    • #1MS (1 Minute's Silence)
    • 3-nine-39 radio and video series
    • 60th Anniversary of the Korean War
    • 70th Anniversary Tobruk 1941
    • 70th Anniversary of the battles for Greece and Crete
    • 70th anniversary of the Kokoda campaign
    • 70th anniversary of the bombing of Darwin
    • 95th Anniversary of the landings on Gallipoli
    • ADSA 2019 Poster
    • Anzac Centenary School Link Program
    • Anzac Day Poster 2019
    • Anzac Day poster
    • Anzac Day poster
    • Australia and the Vietnam War
    • Australian Prisoners of War
    • Australian Service Nursing: Wartime snapshots No.25
    • Australian Women in War
    • Australians at War Film Archive
    • Australians in the Merchant Navy
    • Australians on the Western Front
    • Battle for Leyte Gulf October 1944
    • Centenary of the Flanders Offensive
    • Centenary of the Royal Australian Navy
    • Centenary of the Sinai–Palestine campaign
    • Centenary of the Somme
    • Commemorating Australian Forces in the Vietnam War
    • Commemorating Australian forces in the Korean War
    • Commemorating Australian forces in the Vietnam War 1962–1975
    • Commemorating Australian prisoners of war on the Burma–Thailand Railway
    • Commemorating the Centenary of the Gallipoli Landings
    • Commemorating the Malayan Emergency and Indonesian Confrontation
    • Commemorating the centenary of the Armistice: Wartime Snapshots No. 24
    • Commemorating the first convoy of Australian troops to the First World War
    • Commemorating the return of Australian forces from Afghanistan
    • Control
    • Discovering Anzacs Exhibition Tips and Tools (Learn Area)
    • Discovering Anzacs School and Community Toolkit (Learn Area)
    • Discovering Anzacs Video Tutorials and Timeline (Learn Area)
    • Gallipoli and the Anzacs
    • Great Debates: The Anzac Legend
    • Great Debates—Conscription
    • Here they come—A day to remember
    • INTERFET: History in Focus
    • INTERFET—International Forces for East Timor
    • Indigenous Service
    • Investigating Gallipoli
    • Kokoda: Exploring the Second World War campaign in Papua New Guinea
    • Korea—A Cold War conflict (1950–1953)
    • M is for Mates—Animals in Wartime from Ajax to Zep
    • Ode of Remembrance: Wartime Snapshots No.26
    • Reflections: Capturing Veterans' Stories
    • Remembering Them app—Education Activities
    • Remembrance Day Poster 2019
    • Remembrance Day Posters 2018
    • Remembrance day
    • Schooling, Service and the Great War (Primary Resource)
    • Schooling, Service and the Great War (Secondary Resource)
    • Symbols of Commemoration Cube Education Activities (Secondary)
    • Symbols of Commemoration Cube—Education Activities (Primary school resource)
    • The Flanders Poppy—A symbol of remembrance
    • The Nominal Roll of Australian Korean War Veterans
    • The Nominal Roll of Australian Vietnam War Veterans
    • The Nominal Roll of Australian World War 2 Veterans
    • The Sinking of HMAS Sydney
    • The War that Changed Us Education Activities
    • Their Spirit, Our History
    • Wartime snapshot #23—1918-2018: Centenary of the Final Campaigns
    • We Remember Anzac (Primary Resource)
    • We Remember Anzac (Secondary Resource)
    • We'll Meet Again
    • Women in War radio series
  • Gallipoli and the Anzacs
  • Australians on the Western Front
  • Australia and the Second World War
  • The Burma-Thailand Railway and Hellfire Pass
  • The Kokoda Track
  • Australian involvement in South-East Asian conflicts
  • The Korean War
  • Australia and the Vietnam War
  • Australians on the Western Front
  • The Australian Remembrance Trail
  • Resources
  • Australians on the Western Front
  • The Australian Remembrance Trail
    • Ieper (Ypres)—Belgium
      • What happened here?
      • A walk around Ieper
        • Cloth Hall (Lakenhalle)
        • Ypres War Memorial (Jules Coomansstraat)
        • St George's Church (Elverdingsestraat)
        • St Martin's Cathedral (Vandenpeerboomplein)
        • Lille Street Rijselestraat (Lille Gate)
        • Ramparts Cemetery (Lille Gate)
      • Nearby—The Menin Gate, Ieper
        • Names on the Menin Gate
        • 'Menin Gate at Midnight'
        • Last Post at Menin Gate
      • Nearby—Essex Farm Cemetery
        • Private Barratt
        • Lieutenant Colonel McCrae
      • Nearby—Deutscher Soldatenfreidhof
    • Tyne Cot Cemetery—Zonnebeke
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting—Tyne Cot Cemetery
        • 40th Battalion at Tyne Cot
        • Captain Hurley at Passchendaele
      • Nearby—Fifth Australian Division Memorial
        • Battle of Polygon Wood
        • Buttes New British Cemetery
        • Private Radford
      • Nearby—Menin Road
        • Hooge Crater Cemetery
    • Toronto Avenue Cemetery—Ploegsteert
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting Toronto Avenue Cemetery
      • Nearby—Island of Ireland Peace Park
        • Battle of Messines
        • Pillboxes at Messines
      • Nearby—Hill 60, Zwarte-Leen
        • Tunnels at Hill 60
        • Craters at Hill 60
    • VC Corner—Fromelles
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting Fromelles
        • The Cemetery and Memorial
        • Major McCrae
        • Private Chadwick
        • Sergeant Simon Fraser
        • The 'Nursery'
      • Fromelles (Pheasant Wood) Military Cemetery
        • Exhumation and identification
        • Exhumed objects gallery
        • Cemetery construction
        • Reburial
        • Stories of the dead
      • Nearby—Notre Dame de Lorette French Cemetery and Memorial
        • Battles of Artois 1915
      • Nearby—Canadian National Vimy Memorial
      • Nearby—Zivy Crater Cemetery
        • 'Lunar' landscapes
    • The Bullecourt Digger—France
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting Bullecourt
        • The 'Bullecourt Digger'
        • 48th Battalion at Bullecourt
        • Sergeant White, 22nd Battalion
      • Nearby—Noreuil Australian Cemetery
        • Vaulx to Noreuil
        • Noreuil, 2 April 1917
      • Nearby—Bapaume
        • Bapaume Town Hall
      • Nearby—Butte de Warlencourt
        • Butte de Warlencourt (February 1917)
        • 18th Battalion at Malt Trench
        • Warlencourt British Cemetery
        • Fight for the Loupart Bastion
    • Thiepval Memorial—France
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting Thiepval Memorial
        • Anglo–French Cemetery
      • Nearby—Ulster Tower
        • Lady Munro-Ferguson
      • Nearby—Beaumont-Hamel Newfoundland Memorial
        • Memorial and surrounds
    • First Australian Division Memorial—Pozières
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting the First Australian Division Memorial
        • Capture of Pozières, 23 July 1916
        • Bombardment of Pozières, 24–26 July 1916
        • Charles Bean at Pozières
      • Nearby—Albert
        • Hénencourt Chateau
        • Albert Communal Cemetery Extension
      • Nearby—The road to Pozières
        • Tyneside Scottish and Irish Memorial
        • Lochnagar Crater
        • Gordon Dump Cemetery
        • Sunken Road Cemetery
      • Nearby—Devonshire Cemetery
        • Mametz Wood
    • The Windmill—Pozières
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting the Windmill
        • Capture of Pozières heights
        • 48th Battalion at the Windmill
      • Nearby—The road to Flers
        • Somme Winter
        • 'Les Cavées' (the caves)
        • Gueudecourt (Newfoundland) Memorial
      • Nearby—AIF Memorial
        • Mouquet Farm
        • Sacrifice at Mouquet Farm
    • Australian National Memorial—Villers-Bretonneux
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting Villers-Bretonneux
        • Second battle of Villers-Bretonneux
        • Villers-Bretonneux Military Cemetery
        • The town of Villers-Bretonneux
      • Nearby—Adelaide Cemetery
        • The unknown soldier
      • Nearby—Amiens Cathedral
        • Lieutenant McCartin MC
        • Château de Bertangles
        • Notre-Dame d'Amiens
    • Australian Corps Memorial—Le Hamel
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting the Australian Corps Memorial
        • Battle of Hamel
      • Nearby—Third Australian Division Memorial
        • Sailly-le-Sec (30 March 1918)
      • Nearby—Dernancourt
        • Dernancourt in 1918
        • Dernancourt Cemetery
    • Second Australian Division Memorial—Mont St Quentin
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting Mont St Quentin
        • Mont St Quentin 1918
        • Péronne
      • Nearby—Heath Cemetery
        • Advance to Morcourt Valley
        • The road to Lamotte-Warfusée
    • Fourth Australian Division Memorial—Bellenglise
      • What happened here?
      • Visiting the 4th Australian Division Memorial
        • Hindenburg Outpost Line
      • Of interest—The Forest Clearing of the Armistice
        • Compiègne Forest
        • 11 November 1918
      • Of interest—Palace of Versailles
        • Australia in Paris, 1919
      • Nearby—Calvaire Cemetery
        • The last VC in WWI
        • Captains Fletcher and Mahony
        • Tincourt British Cemetery
  • Resources
    • Audio-casts (x12)
    • Travel options

You are here

  • Home
  • History
  • Conflicts
  • Australians on the Western Front
  • The Australian Remembrance Trail
  • Tyne Cot Cemetery—Zonnebeke, Belgium
  • Nearby—Fifth Australian Division Memorial, Zonnebeke

Buttes New British Cemetery

Just slaughter

After the advance of 26 September 1917 the engineer units of the Fifth Division came up to build strong points and new tracks. Among them was Sapper Leslie McKay, 15th Field Company, Australian Engineers, who was not quite so impressed with the supposed success of the battle:

My God it was terrible. Just slaughter. The 5th Div. were almost annihilated. We certainly gained our objectives but what a cost. Mates I have played with last night and joked with are now lying cold.

Sapper Leslie McKay, diary, 26 September 1917, quoted in Bill Gammage, The Broken Years, Melbourne, 1990, p.204

Captain Ellis admitted that the casualties were 'severe'—545 killed, 172 missing and 2303 wounded. 'But how different a result from the Battle of Fromelles', wrote Ellis, 'over 2000 fewer casualties than on that fatal field'. Fromelles, where the division had suffered more than 5000 casualties in 24 hours for absolutely no gain, was obviously the division's yardstick for measuring disaster.

A colour photo looking across a manicured lawn, at an angle, towards and over rows of white headstones. In the background/behind is the butte with the memorial's obelisk centre in the photo. The border of tall and dark-green trees are all around.
A black and white photo of a ravaged land that bears wooden crosses. There are four soldiers about 50 metres away, walking away and to the left. there are sticks (bare trees or grave markers?) everywhere.
A colour photo looking across a grassy paddock, with two cows (one sitting and one standing and eating). Rows of pine trees are in the background, behind an electric fence.
A black and white photo of three soldiers. One is looking through the scope of a machine gun at an almost vertical angle. One soldier is behind, looking up through binoculars. The third soldier sits on a hill of dirt (side of a trench?), looking up also.

Many of the Fifth Division who died at Polygon Wood have no known grave and they are commemorated on the Menin Gate. In Buttes New British Cemetery lie a few of those killed on 26 September 1917. Private Archibald Cameron, 53rd Battalion (New South Wales), aged 21, from Bogan Gate, New South Wales, was possibly caught by the German barrage which opened on the rear areas after the initial Australian advance. He was wounded badly in the head and advised to go back to a Regimental Aid Post and he was not seen by anyone in the battalion after that. Cameron lies buried in Plot XXX, Row A, Grave 10. One wonders if Sapper John Parker, Plot XXVIII, Row C, Grave 2, and Lance Corporal William White, Plot XXVIII, Row D, Grave 9, were 'mates' joked with and now lamented by Sapper Leslie McKay. Both were members of the 15th Field Company, Australian Engineers, among a group of five men from the unit killed by a high explosive shell on their way up the line after the infantry attack.

A colour photo of a brick wall of around 3-feet high, with a tone brick top. Centre in the photo is the engraved sign for "BUTTES NEW BRITISH CEMETERY 1914 1918".

Stone sign for Buttes New British Cemetery, Polygon Wood. [DVA]

As always, in attacks like those at Polygon Wood, officers led their men forward into enemy fire. Charles Bean, in the official history, mentions by name 32 of the Fifth Division's officers killed or died of wounds between 24 and 28 September, the period of the Polygon Wood battle. One he singled out was Lieutenant Colonel Oswald Croshaw, Queen's Yeomanry, an English officer attached to the division to command the 53rd Battalion (New South Wales). The battalion was the lead unit heading for the Butte and Croshaw, described by Bean as 'one of the noblest British officers in the AIF', led from the front and was killed. Bean reported that Croshaw had a premonition of his fate and addressed these words to his brother officers:

Gentlemen, your men before yourselves. Look to your flanks. God bless you lads till we meet again.

A colour photo of a white headstone which reads: "LIEUTENANT COLONEL | A. H. SCOTT. DSO. | 56TH BN. AUSTRLIAN INF. | 1ST OCTOBER 1917 AGE 27"

Headstone of  Lieutenant Colonel Allan Scott, 56th Battalion (New South Wales), Butte New British Cemetery, Polygon Wood. [DVA]

Strangely, not one officer of the Fifth Division who died during the Battle of Polygon Wood has a grave in Buttes New British Cemetery. But one who fought in the battle is Lieutenant Colonel Allan Scott, the commanding officer of the 56th Battalion (New South Wales), in Plot II, Row A, Grave 12. At 27, Scott, who served with distinction at Lone Pine, Gallipoli, was one of the youngest battalion commanders in the AIF and he was killed by a sniper on 1 October 1917 near the Butte while briefing the commanding officer of a relieving British battalion.

  • Home
  • History
  • Education
  • Multimedia
  • Anzac Day Schools’ Awards Winners
  • Conduct an event
  • Resources
  • Site info
  • Research tips
  • Contact
  • Copyright
  • Events
  • Accessibility
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Links
  • Bibliography
  • Anzac Centenary program

Follow us on Twitter
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to us on YouTube